Why I Haven’t Bought the New Harper Lee (Yet)…

bird file

I have watched my Facebook feed, and I’m fairly certain that I am the only English teacher and Harper Lee enthusiast who hasn’t bought her “new” book.  I didn’t even pre-order it.  While my fellow English teachers utter a collective gasp, I have several reasons.

Before I get into those, I have to admit I’m torn.  My friends are reading this book, and I do somehow feel I’m being left out of the discussion and conversation.  There’s a part of me that wants to run out and buy it and snarf it down by the pool.  But I can’t. I know me.  I’d feel guilty the entire time.

My first career out of university was a medical device sales representative.  I worked with lots of nursing homes and met lots of lovely elderly people of all cognitive functions.  I met many family members who were wonderful, supportive, and loving. I also met the other side.  It isn’t pretty.  I have some concerns, aside from what I’ve read about the investigation, about the recent decision to publish a book near the end of her life.  I’m not sure that I can let go of feelings of others profiting off of the intellectual property of an elderly woman, who until quite recently, was adamant about not publishing anything else. I can’t stomach the thought of a publishing company profiting off of someone in a nursing home who is nearly blind and deaf.  Too many people besides Harper Lee have too much to gain.

My other reason is I’m quite afraid she’ll let me down.  For me, greater than (gasp, again) The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, is To Kill a Mockingbird.  This book is SO powerful.  In the article posted by Tara Fowler on People.com, she asserts:

But if you forget Mockingbird and take Watchman as a standalone novel, it’s a deftly written tale about a young woman coping with the revelation that her father is not the hero she thought he was.

But can you take a novel with the same characters as another novel as a stand alone novel? I’m not sure.  How can I reconcile the Atticus Finch of To Kill a Mockingbird with the Atticus Finch of Go Set a Watchman?  That part is easy.Unlike many others, I’ve never watched Gregory Peck’s portrayal of Atticus, so I don’t have to reconcile the idealized screen version with a character in a book.  What I know is human beings are complex.  Well-written and developed characters should be just as complex. Growing up in Texas, I know many men who would defend a falsely accused man regardless of color but wouldn’t have them over for dinner. Real life is not black and white, and great characters shouldn’t be either. But you cannot take the novels individually. How does one not shape the other?  I cannot read this and forget Mockingbird.

Then there’s the issue of the first draft. If it is in fact a first draft of TKAM, which is what Harper Lee biographer Charles Shields chronicles,  then it should be read and studied as such, not as a separate work.  What’s more interesting is the story of how that draft developed into the beloved novel.  It makes a more appropriate study of the writing process. This is of course my opinion.

On the other side, I know many English teachers and friends who have read the novel in the last week. Some of them have loved it.  Some of them have wondered what all the fuss was about.  Either way they were incredibly happy and joyful about reading it.  That’s the point of reading isn’t it?  That we enjoy it.

Who knows, maybe someday I’ll check it out of the library, but for now, I’m reading other things and enjoying those.

Follow my blog with Bloglovin

6 thoughts on “Why I Haven’t Bought the New Harper Lee (Yet)…

  1. I enjoyed your analysis of why you’re leery of Watchman. I found many of my own thoughts mirrored. I do know that we are in a minority. Even last year so many of my students were aghast that I had not already preordered the book when I’m so in love with TKAM. I think the key is that one would have to take this as a stand alone novel, and I just don’t know if I can. Like you, I also feel that it might be disrespectful to Harper Lee to read something she might have not wanted published. I don’t think we can ever know for sure exactly what prompted this publication. I do know that TKAM is a powerful, timeless novel all on its own.


  2. Pingback: The Millenery’s View on Watchman | Socrates Underground

  3. As soon as I heard about the upcoming publication of this “new” novel, I felt uneasy. And you’re right, it’s probably best read as a study of the writing process, not as a stand-alone novel. (There’s a reason it wasn’t published at first.) Oh well…glad to have found your blog! I’m working my way slowly through Blogging101 and just connected with Tracey (above.) If you’d like to peek at my sites, they are http://www.introvertsdictionary.wordpress.com and http://www.howtobe50.wordpress.com. Looking forward to reading more from you! English teachers and librarians are my favorite people — 🙂


    • Thank you. I attended professional development today with some other teachers. This book came up numerous times. I’m still in the minority, but I stand by my thoughts. Again, thank you for reading!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s